David Harsanyi, author, and columnist, particularly known for his sharp insights on today’s political climate, has a new book. It’s called The Rise of BlueAnon: How the Democrats Became the Party of Conspiracy Theorists.
In a recent conversation with Rob Bluey at The Daily Signal, Harsanyi dug into some fascinating questions. Why have Democrats embraced conspiracy theories? What’s happened to institutional trust in America? And what role does faith play in our society today? Let’s explore some key takeaways from their discussion. Video summary generated by Artificial Intelligence.
The Democrats’ Descent into Conspiracy Theories
Avoiding Real Debate
Harsanyi argues that Democrats have increasingly turned to conspiracy theories as a way to dodge actual debate. Remember when disagreeing with President Obama might get you labeled a racist? Or when Hillary Clinton ran for president, and her opponents were automatically branded as sexists? Harsanyi sees this as a trend that’s only grown, with anyone who opposes the left now being called a fascist.
He believes it’s an easy way out. Instead of grappling with real issues, opponents are simply demonized. Take the claim that asking for voter ID is the “new Jim Crow.” Harsanyi calls these claims “paranoid views of the world” that many everyday Americans simply don’t buy. Could this be one reason why Donald Trump won?
The Russia Collusion Hoax: A Prime Example
For Harsanyi, the Russia collusion narrative is a textbook example. He believes it was “hatched by Democrats,” then eagerly spread by a media that was either complicit or just plain incompetent. Think about it: the idea that a sitting U.S. president is secretly working for Russia? That would be one of the biggest scandals in American history, right up there with the Civil War or the Revolution.
“The most effective conspiracy theory perhaps in political history.”
Harsanyi emphasizes how the Russia collusion narrative undermined almost the entire first term of the Trump administration. In his view, it was like a “soft coup” by intelligence agencies. While he doesn’t usually go around talking about the “deep state,” he admits that something like that clearly exists. He sees the whole episode as a major reason why people have lost trust in the media. And he’s not alone.
Superficial Shifts? Newsom, Emanuel and Going Against The Grain
What about politicians like California Governor Gavin Newsom or former Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel? Are they genuinely trying to engage in conversations with people outside the usual Democratic bubble? Newsom, for instance, has even talked with figures like Steve Bannon and Charlie Kirk on his podcast.
Harsanyi is skeptical. While Rahm Emanuel has always been more of a centrist, he sees Newsom’s moves as potentially superficial. If you’re just changing your views to win elections, Harsanyi suggests, it’s going to come across as insincere. He believes the progressive wing has taken over the Democratic Party, pushing it toward policies that simply don’t resonate with common sense.
The Collapse of Institutional Trust in America
Media’s Role in Spreading Conspiracy Theories
Harsanyi believes everyone is vulnerable to conspiracy theories. The difference, he argues, is that Democrats have been particularly dangerous in recent decades because they control the “megaphones”—the major media outlets.
Because outlets like CNN and The New York Times are taken seriously, their embrace of conspiracy theories is far more damaging than someone like Alex Jones shouting into the void. But now that no one trusts the media, a vacuum has emerged. And it’s being filled by a mix of “interesting people” and “crackpots” from all sides.
Navigating the current news environment can be tough for ordinary folks. It’s more important than ever to:
- Be skeptical.
- Double-check what you’re believing.
The Impact on News Consumption
In today’s world, misinformation spreads like wildfire on social media. How often have you seen something shared online that turned out to be completely false? It’s crucial to be skeptical about what you read. Always look at multiple sources before accepting something as true.
Higher Education’s Crisis: A Hotbed of Extremism?
Harsanyi questions whether we can truly trust higher education institutions anymore. He points to the defunding of Columbia University and the influence of money from countries like Qatar. Have you noticed the presence of what he calls “cosplaying Hamas supporters” on college campuses?
He worries about the lack of intellectual diversity in many schools and calls for the creation of new institutions that are open to all kinds of debate. For him, it starts with the professors and the social science quackery that seems to be going on in these schools.
The Great Institutional Decay
Besides the Supreme Court, Harsanyi wonders if there’s any institution Americans can fully trust. He argues that presidents and Congress have exceeded their constitutional power. Can things be turned around?
Faith’s Crucial Role in Society
The Importance of Organized Religion
Here’s a surprising perspective: Harsanyi is an atheist, but he values religion. He sees organized religion as a culmination of thousands of years of moral thinking. And he believes the loss of faith can have negative consequences, pointing to examples like the Soviet Union and the European Union.
The Erosion of Religious Belief
He’s concerned about the rise of the “nones”—people who don’t subscribe to any particular faith—and the decline in church membership. Harsanyi emphasizes that Christian-majority nations have been historically successful and moral. If that foundation erodes, he fears we’re headed in a bad direction.
His advice? “Even if you don’t believe it, it’s a good idea to act like God exists.” He believes our rights come from a higher power, not from politicians.
Political Idols and the State as a Church
Have you noticed how political symbols, like flags representing specific sexualities, can become like idols? Harsanyi sees this as a kind of “perversion” of what a flag should represent. And what about the way people react to the idea of getting rid of the Department of Education? It’s as if you’re attacking a church.
Charity Giving and the Difference
It’s a well-known fact that conservatives and religious people tend to give more to charity than those with more socialist leanings. Harsanyi believes this is because they understand the importance of community involvement. The more the government taxes, the less inclined people are to give.
The Perversion of Faith
Harsanyi warns against creating “unorthodox perversions of faith” just to bring people in. He sees some Jewish factions as “anti-Jewish,” using the faith to undermine it. He notices similar things happening in some Christian denominations.
Trump’s Actions and Their Lasting Consequences
The Need for Congressional Action
Harsanyi stresses that many of the Trump administration’s actions could be easily reversed unless Congress steps in to codify them into law.
DOGE and the Administrative State
One of Trump’s potential legacies could be his efforts to dismantle the administrative state. Harsanyi believes this would be great for America, but it requires Congress to act.
Reforming Entitlement Programs: A Political Minefield
Why is it so difficult to reform entitlement programs? Because it’s a political minefield. Many politicians are simply unwilling to have the conversation.
Deporting Terrorist Supporters
A Free Speech Debate
The debate continues: can the Trump administration deport individuals who support terrorist groups?
Bad Ideas
Harsanyi argues that the Constitution doesn’t require us to grant citizenship to people who bring nothing but “bad ideas” to the country.
A Matter of National Security?
For Harsanyi, it’s not a free speech issue. It’s a matter of national security. If deporting these individuals is unconstitutional, he believes we should change the law.
David Harsanyi’s Substack and Final Thoughts
The Move to Substack
Why did Harsanyi start a Substack newsletter? He wanted a place to share his cultural picks and add extra context to his writing. His friend Ben Domenech suggested it as a way to connect with more people. You can find it here: David Harsanyi’s Substack.
The Appeal of the Substack Model
Substack is growing rapidly. Could it compete with traditional news brands? Harsanyi compares it to the blog revolution, giving individuals the power to build their own followings.
Engaging with Fans
Substack offers a great opportunity to engage with readers in a thoughtful way, exchanging ideas and even changing his mind on issues.
How to Follow David Harsanyi
Want to keep up with David Harsanyi’s work? Here’s how:
- Twitter: David Harsanyi
- Washington Examiner: Search for David Harsanyi articles on Washington Examiner
Conclusion
David Harsanyi’s insights offer a lot to think about. From the rise of conspiracy theories to the decline of institutional trust and the crucial role of faith, he raises important questions about the direction of our society. Whether you agree with him or not, his perspective is sure to spark some lively debate.
What Would You Do If Pharmacies Couldn’t Provide You With Crucial Medications or Antibiotics?
The medication supply chain from China and India is more fragile than ever since Covid. The US is not equipped to handle our pharmaceutical needs. We’ve already seen shortages with antibiotics and other medications in recent months and pharmaceutical challenges are becoming more frequent today.
Our partners at Jase Medical offer a simple solution for Americans to be prepared in case things go south. Their “Jase Case” gives Americans emergency antibiotics they can store away while their “Jase Daily” offers a wide array of prescription drugs to treat the ailments most common to Americans.
They do this through a process that embraces medical freedom. Their secure online form allows board-certified physicians to prescribe the needed drugs. They are then delivered directly to the customer from their pharmacy network. The physicians are available to answer treatment related questions.
