Let’s get a few points out of the way before anything else is said: There is ZERO scientific evidence to support the notion of gender self identification. There is ZERO scientific evidence to support the claim that gender is merely a social construct. There is more evidence that biology determines gender behaviors and manhood and womanhood are inborn psychological constructs. The vast majority of people develop gender associations directly in line with their biology. Men act like men, women act like women, and these behaviors have been established as biological fact from the beginning of recorded history.
Men and women are biologically different in many respects, even down to how our brains function. Biological sex and gender related behavior are based mostly in nature, not mostly in environment. However, the gender identity religion has deemed these concepts a form of bigotry. The situation has become so unhinged that leftists are now referring to real women as “bleeders” or “people who menstruate,” as if this is the only biological difference between them and trans women.
Regardless of how one is positioned on the topic, if you are honest you have to admit that transgenderism today is a political issue, not a scientific issue. In the past few years we have seen government funded and globalist foundation funded scientists politicized by the gender issue. But, again, they have zero evidence to support their claims that gender is changeable and malleable. Interestingly, they now argue both sides: That gender is purely a social construct, and that gender is biologically linked and hardwired. The two ideas are mutually exclusive, but hey, we’re living in clown world now, so we should just shut up and enjoy the ride…
Are there people out there who feel as though their mental acclimation is not the same as their biological acclimation? Yes, there are exceptions to the rule. In most legitimate cases these people suffer from a mental illness called “gender dysphoria.” It’s a relatively harmless psychological problem (except that it tends to cause depression and suicidal tendencies for the trans person); these people are not a threat to me or to you and their existence in our society is not really our concern, unless, that is, they make it our concern.
For some reason, the authoritarian political left has elevated the transsexual issue to the very top of their oppression Olympics. It’s hard to say why, but they have taken a “group” which represents around 0.4% of the population and determined that they are the pinnacle of the victim totem pole and that the rest of the world needs to walk on egg shells whenever dealing with them.
But let’s look at this situation objectively for a moment, shall we?
The trans community is considered a designated “oppressed minority,” but it’s one that any person can join for any reason. It’s not really a minority group so much as a club, and clubs can become trendy when they are marketed effectively. I don’t have to actually have gender dysphoria to join this club, all I have to do is CLAIM that I identify as trans and, suddenly, I am now part of an oppressed class. The problem is, trans people are not oppressed, at least not in the west.
What the political left deems “oppression” is rather confused and convoluted. In their terminology, oppressing them means not letting them do whatever the hell they please regardless of how destructive their intent. You are victimizing them by not letting them victimize you.
Let’s expand on that in trans terms: If a man claims he is a woman and is trans, that person now has the social power to demand that the rest of us identify him as a woman and use the pronouns he prefers. In other words, if tomorrow I claim I am trans (even though it’s not true) I then have the right to control your speech. And yes, it is absolutely as simple as that according to leftists.
A vivid example of this control dynamic is the reaction to the recently passed Florida Anti-Grooming Bill, which SJWs and the media dishonestly labeled the “Don’t Say Gay Bill.” Here we have a law based in logic and reason which victimizes no one, turned into a circus under accusations of bigotry and discrimination. What does the bill do? It prevents public school teachers from exposing children as young as Kindergarten to discussions on sexuality and gender identity, and requires that they talk to parents about their child’s exposure to any such lessons. In other words, Florida is telling teachers they’re not allowed to propagandize children with their cultist nonsense and groom them into the SJW/trans fold.
Public school teachers are paid by the state and the taxes that parents pay to the state. The teachers work for the parents; the parents are the boss. But leftists don’t see it that way. They say it’s about free speech, and at bottom they they aren’t school employees, they are evangelists for the social justice cause. They are widely against religious ideas being taught in schools, unless it’s their own religion.
The truth is they are zealots. They believe their ideology supersedes all other concerns and that they have the right to mold your children into that ideology without your approval because they believe you are too ignorant to understand the “greater good” that is being done.
The anti-grooming bill was designed to protect young children from sexual indoctrination, and leftists are furious about it. They claim ownership of your children, and the trans agenda is a big part of the molding process that leftist teachers say they have a right to pursue.
As you can imagine, the temptation for narcissistic and sociopathic miscreants to jump on the trans bandwagon is immense. All they have to do to gain control over the people around them is to join a gender identity group? All they have to do to get special treatment and privileges is proclaim they are discriminated against? For people without conscience this is an exciting new world where their narcissism is applauded and protected.
If people don’t comply, they are “oppressing” the trans individual and are now automatically bigots. Frankly, I will never refer to a trans person according to their preferred pronouns. Why? Because this is a lie. They are not what they claim to be. Their internal fantasies are irrelevant to the facts, and their feelings do not matter where the truth is concerned. There is no such thing as “their truth,” there is only THE TRUTH.
If the issue at hand is gender dysphoria, then we must approach it like any other mental illness. When dealing with a schizophrenic that believes he is Napoleon or Elvis Presley, we don’t demand that the whole of society agrees with him and enables his fantasies and makes laws protecting the validity of his delusions, right? We ignore his fantasies; we don’t adapt our entire culture to his whims. Why are we doing this with trans activists?
Much of what the political left does involves making their problems into your problems, and it’s mostly about control, not equality. They claim they are victims, and therefore they believe they have the right to determine what is oppression and what is bigotry. I ask, who made them the virtue police and how are they actually qualified? Most of these people are so stunted and biased they hardly measure up to the high standards that would be required to pass such objective judgments. Leftists aren’t the most virtuous, they are the most unstable, and yet they are being positioned as the arbiters of our morality.
I focus on trans women specifically in this article because while there are women who pretend they are men, these women generally aren’t trying to invade men’s spaces and take them over. There is something rather predatory and malicious about the trans woman aspect of this movement.
Most of the world is probably now familiar with the bizarre case of Lia Thomas (aka William Thomas), a biological man cosplaying as a woman so that he can compete in the women’s NCAA swimming championships and destroy all the other real women competitors. Leftists argue that keeping Lia Thomas and those like him out of women’s competitions would be oppressive, but is it really? Is acknowledging scientific fact “bigotry?”
The most glaring catalyst for the whole scenario is feminism. It’s ironic that feminists have misrepresented the male-to-female social dynamic for so long that regular women actually began to believe the leftist world view, and now it’s coming back to bite them on the ass.
For decades, feminists have been arguing that women and men are equal in every possible way, including in physicality. This delusion has become dangerously pervasive, not just in Hollywood but in the real world. We have even had the US military recently attempting to integrate women into frontline combat and ranger battalion roles, to the point that they had to rig the standards in the women’s favor just so they could pass the grueling tests. Other more honest experiments, such as those conducted by the US Marines into mixed gender units, show that this is a terrible idea. Not only are mixed units distracted by sexual concern, but male/female units perform poorly in almost every area of training compared to all male units.
Today, the trans athlete issue is proving beyond a doubt that men are physically superior to women. There is no debate. Even Lia Thomas, a man ranked in the 400s in male swimming, has dominated women’s swimming easily. The examples are becoming widespread, from women’s weightlifting to women’s MMA fighting and women’s track and field. If you want to crush the competition in women’s sports, all you have to be is a man.
If women want to save their sports, they are going to have to admit that the feminists were wrong and that men are physically superior. And, this is probably one of the primary reasons why very few women in sports have spoken up. They have been conditioned for so long to notions of equity, they can’t handle the truth of biological reality.
The other reason is that if they do speak up they face the prospect of becoming social pariahs and being ostracize. Of course, the majority of Americans think cancel culture is garbage, but the political left controls the corporate environment including Big Tech and most of government; they can make it appear as if they are the majority when they are not. Even if they were the majority that does not mean they are not crazy. It is pure madness to deny facts that are right in front of your face just to achieve political ends, but leftists have been doing this for some time now.
There are trans people that are not on board with the leftist agenda. Bruce Jenner (aka Caitlyn Jenner) has been surprisingly outspoken against woke propaganda. Blair White is another example of an anti-leftist trans figure willing to speak out. The liberty movement and conservatives have widely embraced them even though leftists claim we “hate” trans people and want to see them erased. The fact is that most of us don’t care what people do in their private lives. But, when you weaponize and politicize your sexual proclivities and declare that we owe you something, that’s when we’re going to have a problem.
Ultimately, the trans community is so minuscule it begs the question – Why are these people relevant in the grand scheme of things? Because leftists see an opportunity to use them as tools for social derailment? Why are leftists so obsessed with the idea of indoctrinating children into the trans fold? Why are they so interested in undermining biological fact? What is it with leftists and their need to turn the world upside down?
Many of them know, deep down, that the ideologies they preach are not based in truth. They know that they lie, and some of them are openly proud when their lies prove effective. They are clearly not interested in enlightenment, they are only interested in winning. But what does it mean for the political left to “win.” Well, in Marxist/communist terms, winning means destroying everything and tearing the target society down to nothing. And if that’s what winning is to them, I’m more than happy to act as a gatekeeper that shuts them down and keeps them out as much as possible. Gatekeeping in this case is good.
It’s sad that real people with real gender dysphoria are caught in the middle of this battle for the stability of our society. They should no be used as pawns in the culture war. But then again, perhaps it’s time for more of them to speak up if they are not in support of the woke agenda. I think this farce has gone on long enough, don’t you? As insane as leftists are, maybe we are more insane for letting the patients run the asylum.
Article cross-posted from Alt-Market.
Isn’t “follow the science a leftist mantra”?
It’s now easier and more realistic than ever in history to earn a substantial income from the comfort of your own home! HERE…….. https://brightfuture32.blogspot.com/
There is no such thing as transgender. No amount of hormones or plastic surgery will change that. A man in a dress will always be a man in a dress. Any man that thinks wearing women’s clothes will magically make his life all better has mental issues and needs help, not encouragement.
‘T’ is a sick fraud – a mental health derangement i.e. a lies r us scam. To agree with it is to encourage it and validate it. Only weak minded, gullible people will.
If Penn swimmer Lia Thomas was found guilty of murder, and her case came before the Supreme Court… Would judge Jackson send her to a men’s prison or a women’s prison?
Whatever it chooses…..
It is also medical insanity – consider two situations:
1. You are a doctor in the ER. A 5 foot 6 inch 70 pound teenage girl with skin sores of protein-calorie malnutrition presents and has a chief complaint that she is “Too Fat”. You do NOT refer her to a weight loss clinic for hyperbaric surgery. You realize that her belief that she is “Too Fat” is a bodily dysmorphic delusion that is part of her psychiatric disease of Anorexia Nervosa and refer her to life-saving psychiatric therapy. THIS IS HOW REAL MEDICINE HAPPENS.
2. You are a doctor in the ER. A 6 foot 3 inch 220# heavily muscled male with XY chromosomes and normal male genitalia presents with a chief complaint that he “feels that he is a woman inside”. You now that this is a delusional belief by the evidence of the exam and laboratory tests that show he is a biological male. But for some reason, you are called on by political types and an absurd change in the psychiatric nomenclature to pretend that his delusion is real, pretend that he is actually a woman and indistinguishable from biological women despite not having the same organs, one structure and many other key facets of being a woman, refer him to surgeons to mutilate his body so that it will then falsely appear to be female, fulfilling his delusional belief. THIS IS HOW POLITICIZED POOR MEDICINE OCCURS.
Human beings managed to rise from subsistence living in the Savannah grasslands, invent agriculture, invent civilization, invent science and technology, split the atom, land on the moon and create great literature based on the use of our brains to assimilate facts, develop the concepts to understand those facts, figure out what is likely actually true and act based on our powers of reasoning. Telling people to ignore irrefutable facts, ignore what they know to be scientifically true, inflict medical harm surgically or through industrial grade administration of powerful sex hormones is the opposite of letting them use their minds. Using cancel culture and professional intimidation as well as physical assaults on them to intimidate them into kowtowing to saying something is true that they know is false is the opposite of letting them use their minds. This is a huge social error – the same sort of hysterical error that let the Salem Witch Trials happen, that let the Nazi Eugenic campaigns to purify the Aryan race, that led the completely wrong biology of Lysenko that Stalin supported for political reason be employed and cause a famine that killed up to 30 million people.
First, reality exists independent of a person’s perception of it or his wishes to change it. A human born with a Y chromosome is male. He may desire or even believe himself to be female, but he is not. Second, surgery and hormones do not make a female out of a male. They make a male that has suppressed his male characteristics. Third, how does anyone know what it “feels” to be a man or a woman. I am a man, and I am comfortable with being a man, but I don’t exactly know what being a man “feels like.” Is it being attracted to women, watching football, and liking bacon, etc.? No, because many men are attracted to other men, don’t watch football and eschew bacon. Many women are attracted to other women, watch football, and eat bacon. There is no way to know whether one “feels like a man” or “feels like a woman.” There is only feeling comfortable as a man or comfortable as a woman. A man that arranges flowers and likes wearing women’s underwear is not engaging in standard male behavior, but he can still do so and be comfortable with himself as a man. People that do not feel comfortable with their biological sex have a mental problem: their perception of reality does not match up with reality. They should seek mental help to align their perception with reality, not surgery to try and make reality align with their incorrect perception. For example, I am white. If I said I self-identify as a Japanese and have always felt that way, it would indicate a mental problem. If I colored my skin and hair and had surgery on my eyes and said, “Now I AM Japanese,” no one would accept that, and properly so. Everyone knows that you cannot change your race by surgery or cosmetics, so why do people pretend that you can change your sex/gender by surgery or cosmetics. I feel compassion for people with mental problems, but that does not mean I will pretend their perception of reality is correct and reality itself is not correct. Pretending that someone who is sick is actually well is not doing them a favor, and it undermines the very concepts of facts and truth. The potential harm to all of society is immense!
Right now Orwell is screaming “Called it!” from his grave. According to lefties 2+2=5, and if you have a problem with that you’ll be cancelled and ostracized. Tomorrow you’ll be tortured.
Surgery below the shoulders can’t cure an illness above the neck.
They are nuts and those that pander to them are too.